Emancipation Proclamation: A Primary Source Analysis

5 Ws

View Activity

Excerpt Analysis

View Activity

Timeline

View Activity

Text vs. Rationale

View Activity

What It Means to Me

View Activity

Discussion Questions for The Emancipation Proclamation

1. What was the document's purpose?
2. How did the Emancipation Proclamation influence the outcome of the Civil War? Slaves’ status?
3. How can we interpret the Proclamation as a military tactic? A moral document?
4. How did different segments of Americans view and interpret the document? What did it mean to them and why?
5. Why is the Proclamation a defining document of American History?
6. Why/how did the Emancipation Proclamation set a precedent of human freedom for future generations?
   

   What Was the Emancipation Proclamation?

   The institution of slavery was one reason the country was engulfed in civil war. States wanted to be able to have more control over whether or not a state, both existing and future, would have legal slavery. Slave labor was extremely profitable for many plantation owners and many people did not want to give up their wealth or dependence on a free labor force. The Civil War began in April of 1861 when South Carolina seceded from the Union.

   Created in 1862, the Proclamation was enacted January 1st, 1863. In it, Abraham Lincoln carefully words the provisions and actions that will not only secure a Union victory, but also free those presently enslaved. Lincoln first declares all slaves to be freed in rebellious states, leaving slavery to still exist in the border states to ensure their loyalty. Lincoln also declares that all slaves who choose to fight for the Union will be granted freedom. Over 180,000 African American soldiers joined the Union ranks, proving instrumental in the Union’s victory. The document itself was key to ending both the Civil War, and slavery in the United States.

   By analyzing this document, students will be able to connect and explain the motives behind it and its implications for the presidency and the nation. Students will also be able to interpret the complex language of the time, to better understand and connect it to today’s political and social world. Through the activities above, students can gain a holistic perspective on one of the defining documents of human rights.

   
   

   How Tos about Emancipation Proclamation: A Primary Source Analysis

   1

   How to facilitate a classroom debate on the Emancipation Proclamation’s impact

   Set clear debate guidelines. Explain the debate format and expectations so students know how to respectfully share ideas.

   2

   Choose engaging debate topics related to the Proclamation

   Select topics that spark discussion, like whether the Emancipation Proclamation was more a military tactic or a moral statement. Students will consider multiple perspectives.

   3

   Assign students roles to represent different viewpoints

   Give students roles such as Union soldier, Confederate leader, enslaved person, or abolitionist. This encourages empathy and deeper understanding.

   4

   Provide supporting sources for evidence-based arguments

   Offer primary and secondary sources, including excerpts from the Proclamation and reactions from historical figures. Students can cite facts to back up their claims.

   5

   Encourage reflection after the debate

   Ask students to write or share what they learned and how their views may have changed. This consolidates learning and connects history to today.

   Frequently Asked Questions about Emancipation Proclamation: A Primary Source Analysis

   What is the Emancipation Proclamation and why is it important for students to study?

   The Emancipation Proclamation was a landmark executive order by President Abraham Lincoln in 1863 that freed enslaved people in rebellious states during the Civil War. Studying it helps students understand its impact on American history, civil rights, and the end of slavery.

   How did the Emancipation Proclamation affect the outcome of the Civil War?

   The Proclamation shifted the focus of the war to ending slavery, encouraged thousands of African Americans to join the Union army, and weakened the Confederate states, helping secure a Union victory.

   Why is the Emancipation Proclamation considered a turning point in American history?

   The Proclamation redefined the Civil War as a fight for freedom, set a precedent for human rights, and laid the groundwork for the abolition of slavery in the United States.

   How can teachers use primary source analysis activities for the Emancipation Proclamation in class?

   Teachers can engage students with primary source analysis by examining the language, motives, and impact of the document. Activities might include group discussions, debates, and connecting the Proclamation to modern issues.

   What was Abraham Lincoln’s main motive for issuing the Emancipation Proclamation?

   Lincoln aimed to preserve the Union and undermine the Confederacy by freeing slaves in rebellious states, while inspiring moral support and encouraging enlistment of African American soldiers.